~WILY Week 4 addendum…sorry!

Two things happened last week – met a  load of new contacts at a media type of networking meeting – Thanks Steve Blacknell for making all the Waffle Club stuff happen!  Nice people, great fun. (link to his biog on IMdB ).  And, as eclectic an array of folk as you will find anywhere…which was part of the fun.

The other big item last week was my single tweet about the NHS – regarding a meeting I summarised in a blog below – The Future of Primary Care.  What was particularly splendid was the number of hits the blog received – well over 600.  Thanks to Roy Lilley for giving me the shout out in his e newsletter. (if you want to read the blog – scroll down…

Thanks all.

#WILY – What I Learnt Yesterday – week 4

Another eclectic week of non related thought provocation…

(After nearly a month at this, I am realising that the book could be hard to pull together.  Easiest as a diary of dailies – but feel I may have to coalesce the themes.  Looking like politics, Orgnisational life, Sport as metaphor, Daily Grind, The NHS in the UK – and public / private healthcare and how we afford it worldwide (long chapter!), and quotes to make you think)

So, back to Week 4:

Embedded image permalink

Quotes – one I re-tweeted: Nelson Mandela. above. Doesn’t that sum up how to get people on side??  And then another lesson in the effect Twitter (and other social media) has on making 6 degrees of separation (as was) much less.  Some commentators reckon it is now 4 or less.  You are only 4 contacts away from being able to contact The Queen or President Obama.  Sounds impossible, until news this morning that someone had managed to speak to our Prime Minister and head of GCHQ just by asking to be put through via the switchboard!  I fellow Nigella Lawson on twitter, and she does have some lovely recipes and ideas.  But someone asked her about what to do if it all goes belly up in the kitchen.  She offered two quotes which had wider significance than just the heat of the kitchen:

“Don’t be scared to learn to fail really well”  (A Buddhist saying that Ms Lawson had said she had just learnt after 47 years (assume that is her age?)

“Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try Again. Fail again. Fail better.”  (Samuel Beckett).

So food and life can give you quotes for working and the daily grind?  Thank you, Nigella!

My own quote this week was from a client, paraphrasing me: “”You can’t change the past, only shape the future” good reminder not to wallow, but to plan positively. Learn from what you have done in the past, use it to plan, and act on it.  Be more Tigger than Eeyore?

We are having some work done at home, and had seen some magnificent and clever black out blinds from Luxaflex – via an old family firm, Gilroys in Gerrards Cross.  The owner and person who came and measured asked us why we wanted such expensive kit.  We told him we may be moving in the year, so he specified some much cheaper options, which we listened to, then decided on an in-between solution.  An honest salesman always gets repeat business, was my learning from that encounter.

Personally?  Loved the magic of the FA Cupsets again. Just great to see the ‘minnows’ – lower league sides – holding or beating their effete Premier league counterparts.  SO exciting – especially on radio.  No idea why – it just sounds so full on when flitting between matches in the last 10 minutes of the games on radio 5 Live – BBC at it’s best.

We are having work done as i said – always a good time to have a cull of  all teh crap you tend to accumulate (or is it just me?)  Three trips to the dump – half of the stuff to the clever re-use centre, whose rofit goes to a local hospice. And trips to three charity shops – more on that next week.  And did another 5 km run – no ill effects apart from stiff this morning – up hill running is just such a killer…

Aiming to run in Marlow 5 miler in May…missed last year injured. I am excited! (Must get out more).

marlow 5 mhance Eric 60 003

The Future of Primary Care – Addendum

Hi all.  Yesterdays blog has created a lot of noise and traffic – thank you Roy Lilley of nhs,managers.net – link to e newsletter

If anyone else wants to get in touch who has read the piece and the blog, go via one of my websites

www.philhawthorn.com

or

www.onsetpaheadtraining.co.uk 

Yes, as Roy said today “we never reached a conclusion and it is too important a topic to just leave hanging”.  We do need to stop talking action and start taking action.

Looking forward to hearing from some of you!

PhilRoy Lilley with me ("The Tie")

The Future of Primary Care

OK – we are talking General Practice here, as most of us know it.  I was at one of Roy Lilley’s Health Chats last night at The Kings Fund in London.

All friends together...

All friends together…

Roy Lilley was our Paxman for the session. He floated questions, hypotheses, challenged, derided, abused and cajoled Claire Gerarda, (past chair of RCGP) James Kingsland (President NAPC) and Mike Bewick (Deputy Medical Director, NHS England). And an audience of GPs and many other interested parties…were exercised to intervene too.

But there was positivity in the title…assuming we do have future need. The title wasn’t about the future of the GP, or even General Practice. It was about primary care.  Here are my madly biased highlights ….it was all so full on and frantic, that I am sure everyone there heard different things, depending on their individual need and their own biases. Ears are tuned differently.

Roy wouldn’t invest if he was presented this model on Dragons Den.   The main question was “what will Primary Care look like in 2020” ( a 20:20 vision if you will!).

...and my second point is...

…and my second point is…

Roy is provocative, as is the need of the occasion. Even if we don’t believe he believes it, at least people have to defend their position. Suggestion first, possible actions later, and my bits in (parentheses) in the main: Here’s the visions: (Claire, James, Mike: 3 from each)

  •  Still be – gatekeeper (good value – 8% of budget, 80% of contact). Saves money and stops you doing stupid, e.g. “cancer tests on demand” – What? What for? Why? (worried well can cost a fortune!) We will still need translators of undifferentiated symptoms.  The world wants and is aiming for a primary care led health service.  Why do we want to go the other way?  (Government hates the BBC too…)
  • Get rid of independent practitioner status?  (James disagreed)
  • It won’t be like now – I won’t be working from Hurley Clinic – it will be more Lambeth Primary Care Organisation
  • Primary Care Multi-Specialist team, mainly in the community still
  • Will still be personalised care – efficient care system, not disenfranchised
  • PBC will re-replace CCG! (Full circle, history repeats – pendulum always swings fully in change management – need to stop the extremes…)
  • 300 000 needed for efficient commissioning
  • Health and social care need to be together and seen as holistic (like it used to be?)
  • Let the technology breathe – near patient testing, ambulances containing clinical expertise, change our heads!

And here’s some of the other highlights (for me): Questions are Roy’s, in the main.

  • “Wny not just have it in Tescos?” –  (because we can’t trust them to run their own business…) You don’t understand Roy: It’s not where is it – it is what I do that matters.  It’s about continuity of care.
  • We see symptoms, not diagnoses.
  • Very elderly – maybe need a new model of holistic plus social care (and maybe get rid of poly pharmacy – every older person on 5 drugs max??? No need for medicines to counter side effects – how stupid is that?)
  • There is no one size fits all.  Darzi (he never mentioned Poly Clinics…) may fit the London model, but elsewhere? (Two NHS’s – London and the rest of England / UK?)
  • “What about just moving you all to A&E?” Research shows you become an A&E consultant – over investigating, because it is there.  Not Family Doctor anymore…and we feel that is still the essential
  • More hospital specialists and other experts (e.g. Specialist Nurses in Diabetes and Stoma, as examples that already happen – just stop calling them outreach clinics.  Your expert is her in the building!)
  • No GP surgeries are in special measures – fact (whatever Daily Mail would have us believe)
  • Health services around the world are unaffordable without being GP led
  • We need to take away some of the perverse incentives of some targets

More heat than light?  More questions than answers?  For sure.  But maybe one of the things that needs to change is the attitude towards change.  For example, we do need to have access to our own data (Look, everyone who was there last night is also a potential patient.  Don’t you want to know your own data? And not to have to convince a receptionist that you should have access because you may know more than your generalist GP (it’s in the title) knows, if, for example, you are a Biochemist?)

Claire said something fundamental early on. “There is nothing so beautiful as going to visit a dying patient in their home. I am a generalist not a specialist. I want to see and help the sore throats the depressions and the like. And to see the dying patient.”

Holistically and psychologically, everyone wins in that close encounter. The bean counters may say “someone else should do that, not good use of your skills”. I’m sorry. It is. For the dying person. For their family and friends, and for the GP. I don’t care what it looks like. I want it to feel like Claire described.

#WILY Week 3

What I Learnt Yesterday – week 3 – is all about the same sort of eclectic learning that happens everyday – because everyday is a school-day, and when you stop learning you stop growing.

It is a bit weird looking back at a week of tweets…I am realising I have a very wide range of interests, looking almost random, but the thing that links them all is people and soft skills.  This is why I am publishing them on this site (But the occasional food or eating metaphor may slip through…I can’t stop my @canmencook mentality either!)

Here’s some highlights:

  • Intolerance – we always think our way is best and only?
  • Weather forecasts – sometimes scare you and don’t prove correct
  • Chicken metaphors are great
  • New projects are scary but great once you get going
  • Praise is priceless
  • John Lewis know Customer Service.

Chicken? No, not the silly spat in cocooned Westminster, but a delegate on a course. “If you treat and feed a chicken well, you get better eggs”.  The workshop was about  Banter or bullying, and how to draw the line – but the quote has wider implications.  It is why praise is good, managers who coach and train have more successful teams who are high achieving, and a positive inclusive environment helps everyone work more effectively.Not bad from one chicken!

The praise bit was my sister, a school secretary, who had to stand up and present a piece of software to a highfalutin audience. She also had to demo it.  She moved from being rather Eeyore (from Winnie the Pooh) about it, to being decidedly Tigger when the Chair texted her after (how modern) to praise her. She is presenting it again in high spirits today to the teachers, and now instead of panicking, just said “Bring it On!”.

John Lewis needs more explanation. My auntie (severe Rheumatoid arthritis; husband with Alzheimers and Parkinsons; and a little bit of social care) had bought a new lighter vacuum cleaner.  My sister (she has done a lot of good stuff this week!) had fitted it together but auntie couldn’t even press the on switch.  Old scool, she said “I’ll just have to put up with it” Instead they took it back, and the assistant (sorry, Partner) at JL in Liverpool, took one look at auntie, and took the first vaccum back no question.  Then spent 30 minutes working togetehr to find one that she could cope with.  And they have done and it works and everyone is happy.

Well done John Lewis (and sis for taking the initiative).  JL Partnership obviously know how to feed and treat their chickens!

Izzy - Time Share Dog

Izzy – Time Share Dog

(This week we also looked after a time share dog – my friend, Julian is away a lot so has to farm out Izzy.  We missed her yesterday after she had gone home. Gives me a chance to put a gratuitous ‘ahhh’ pic in though…)

#WILY week 2

What I Learnt Yesterday is my Twitter stream which I produce daily at 08:15 (it was going to be 20:15 to align with the year, but more people look at their Twitter at 08:15 than 20:15 – so it’s as near as I can get!)

It has been quite challenging – hitting 08:15 precisely – Twitter doesn’t like pre-publishing drafts to just pop out at  a certain time – otherwise advertisers would swamp the network). So I am trying, and it will be as near as I can get.

There will only be one picture from last week at the bottom of the post. It was Thursday’s tweet. You will know what it was about already.

If you didn’t catch them all – they were as eclectic as week 1 (I am learning a lot about myself!).

  1. No FA Cupsets – lovely word for when a lower league team achieves a giant killing act.  It was close in some.  It is gladiatorial in sport – and lower league performers can succeed. Think of new upstarts or a new competitor?  See – the metaphor does transfer from sport?  Metaphor / analogy is one of the best ways of gleaning your own bit of learning each day you are on this earth.
  2. I got a bit exercised by the start of an election campaign in the UK. I suppose we always knew with the advent of a coalition and  fixed term parliaments, that we would suddenly become quasi american and have much longer campaigns.  I already hate the narcissistic negativity.  No-one is saying what they would do.  Only what the others would screw up.  How damned annoying is that?  And they, the Westminster Elite, wonder why we are disengaged?  Perhaps a box saying ‘none of the above’, and if that was the winner, then there would be no MP for that constituency? And don’t get me started on lack of democracy – in safe seats, your dissenting voice will have no effect.  That is not democratic.
  3. It was strange getting going after a couple of weeks off – as much for me as for my colleagues and clients.  No-one was contactable on Monday.  By Thursday, everyone wanted to chat!
  4. My big learning this week was in one day with client meetings.  Mainly to do with managing performance – and how to create a high performing team. Praise and improvement was a simple concept we chatted about.  This fits for the sporting links too.  It is much easier to add to what is going well than to try to turnaround something that is going badly.  Build on the positives (Politicians – I don’t expect you to listen.  But you should do this too.  Or shut up).  But if performance is bad?  Sometimes, we have to forget coaching and an inclusive approach.  Tell is the direct way:  3 E‘s -model for improvement:  Give an Example of the behaviour or input that needs to change;  Tell the person the Effect it is having on you, other people in the organisation, or the processes;  tell them your Expectation going ahead of here.  Then, (and only then) ask them what actions they will take to make that happen.  No discussion – just tell it as it is.  Powerful stuff…it works.  The final quote was Privilege or Entitlement?  Some staff get spoilt in good organisations, and take advantage.  You do have to remind people that they are getting that piece of slack, that bonus, that support as a privilege – it is not just a baseline entitlement.  If they abuse the privilege them they should lose it.

Finally, after Paris, I published just a photo I took on Thursday morning, at my desk.  I don’t draw.  I love the way cartoonists help us to make sense of the senseless.  But here it is.  #JeSuisCharlie

P1070064